Permalink
I had some sort of idea for what kind of sound I wanted in the animation, as I knew I wanted the sound to be quite ambient, as well as have a sort of ‘vintage’ sound to fit with the silent movie/film noir aesthetic. I also wanted it to be quite moody, as well as creepy; something along the lines of Garry Schyman’s work for the Bioshock games. Other than this I had no idea, so I wanted to get the animation done so I could hand it over to Stuart Blakeledge as far as musical composition went - as he knows best!
I also knew that I didn’t want any voices in the animation, for a lot of reasons. I don’t think they would have really suited the animation or added anything to it, and to get a good voice actor would have been quite difficult given the time span. It would have also bought about a lot of complex issues such as recording, and getting the right voice and mood. On top of this it wouldn’t have fitted with the silent movie look to have sound, and I wanted to include the use of the title cards.
I think the one main reason I didn’t want to include voices however, is that I am unconfident in my writing; and to have effectively written a ‘script’ is something that is very daunting to me. An actor can get away with saying things in a tone that doesn’t quite fit, but if the writing is bad it really stands out.
One of the only things I wasn’t sure on was wether to include foley art or not. I didn’t want to originally as I wanted it to be a ‘silent’ movie - and therefore there would have been no pre-recorded sound synced to it. It came up in the crit though and I felt like I should do some, such as creaks when the door opens or sound effects of the steam hissing.
After the animation was finished however, I played it back and the story comes across fine (to me, at least), and I asked my housemates/friends what they thought of it, and whether or not it needed the extra sound effects. They agreed with me in that it didn’t, as it wouldn’t have made sense with the title cards.
Also, once the powerful musical score Stuart created was added, there was a whole new level to the animation, and it tied it all together nicely without the need for additional sound effects or narration.